Photo by Kaylee Vaughn
On her debut album, Full Circle, Schaefer Llana invites you into her world, one where you close the door behind you and wander through dusky, dreamy rooms, not so much taking inventory as letting the warmth envelop you. The Mississippi songwriter blends Southern spice, Nashville rhythms, and Southwestern spaciousness, an Americana-tinged Mazzy Star, if you will, and her tender vocals land like lullabies.
Full Circle has been a long time coming. Llana spent years as a sidewoman for artists like the Squirrel Nut Zippers and Shinyribs (who she still performs with), and though she has released music of her own before, she sees those earlier efforts as an artist still searching for her voice. This album, finally made once she had time to devote herself to the recording process, is the one she considers her true introduction to the world. Released earlier this month, Full Circle is a true treasure, and it arrives just in time to shake up year-end lists that seemed all but settled.
This is your first album on a label, but you’ve been performing for a while. What has the journey looked like to get here?
SCHAEFER: This is the first album on a label. I have released singles through a label, and I released an album independently when I was in college, which I have taken off the internet. If anyone knows about it and asks me for it, I’ll give it to them. So this is not technically my first recording venture, but it is my first album released through a label.
Do you wish this album had come out three, four, five years ago? Or did everything come together so that this is the right time?
SCHAEFER: I think it could have come out at any point. We recorded it over two years ago. You know personally how much you can change in just a year. Some of those songs I wrote even before recording, so they could be even older than that. I think it could have come out at any time, and I’m honestly not that precious about dates.
I worked with David Barbe, recording vocals for one of the (Drive-By) Truckers’ records, and he said, “You don’t remember the day that your favorite album came out?” And I thought, “You’re so right.”
There’s a kid every day hearing a Beatles record for the first time, and for that kid, the Beatles are a brand-new band. Do you think of your music as timeless, or is this record a photograph of the moment you made it?
SCHAEFER: I would love to be considered an artist who makes timeless music. I’ve talked about that a lot with my songwriter friend Spencer Thomas. But that could mean anything. It’s really up to the listener. For this album specifically, I was trying to capture a moment and stay very present with it. I was really trying not to spend forever on something, trying to make it a masterpiece, and then end up never finishing it.
My big goal for this record was to take inspiration from Jimbo Mathus, a Mississippi songwriter who has been a mentor to me. He has this ethos of: just go in and do it, and let it be, and keep moving on, and keep making, and learn from that and take that with you. But don’t get so bogged down in trying to make it perfect, because what is that even, anyway?
To add to that thought, when I would work in the studio with Matt Patton, he was always saying that recordings are just photographs. It’s just the way that you played it in that moment.
You’ve taken your older music offline. Was it that you didn’t want people to revisit that photograph, or that you didn’t feel confident in the songs?
SCHAEFER: I made that record in college with the same people who helped me with this record. I love that record, I’m really proud of it, and I think it was important to a lot of people in that scene at the time. I ultimately decided to take it off the internet, which I know goes against some of what I just said.
I don’t play any of those songs anymore. They kind of only exist in that time for me, and carrying them into this new realm of my career didn’t feel like the best representation of the way that I play music now. I have no problem sharing it. But when I was trying to book shows or describe to people how I sound, it’s not how I sound in a live setting anymore. It’s very loud and more rock-leaning. It was really fun and felt very important at the time, but in this stage of my life, I couldn’t get away from it for a second. I needed to lay a foundation of what I want.
So it was about establishing your identity as an artist going forward?
SCHAEFER: Correct, yes. No one wants to be defined entirely by what they did at 20 years old, or whatever.
Is this album a kind of greatest hits, with songs that have been building up over the years, or did you write a lot for this record?
SCHAEFER: I wrote for the record. “Mindless Feeling” was bouncing around for a while. We couldn’t figure it out. It’s actually maybe the oldest song on the record. Then I did two songs by Jimbo, because when I was playing with him a lot, we would do both of those, and he would have me sing lead on “KK’s Blues.” In some ways I felt very possessive of that song and really wanted to have my version of it.
Some of them I just had ideas for, and when we were in the studio, I would show them what I had, and whatever made them excited, that’s what I would add on to. So some of that just happened in the moment.
Your music is hard to pin down. It’s not really Americana, but I love the sound of it. How do you describe it?
SCHAEFER: Not well. I would say it’s anywhere from Americana to indie to singer-songwriter, whatever that means. I’ve heard a lot of people refer to it as atmospheric.
I have this background in pop, growing up listening to a lot of pop music: Celine Dion and Christina Aguilera and Britney Spears. Then, when my sister hit middle school, she’s older than me), and she was listening to Fall Out Boy, so I started getting into alternative music. By high school and college, I’m listening to indie, independent, alternative, anything. After that, I discovered my favorite musicians, which are all ladies of the ’70s. So whatever amalgamation that brings about is, I think, where I land.
Where did your musical education come from?
SCHAEFER: It really all started with growing up in the church. I think that’s where my biggest foundation of music was. My mom sang in the choir, my grandmother sang in the choir, and my mom really loved those ’80s power-ballad singers, big voices. So that was already playing against the hymns in the background.
Then, as my sister got older and iPods were a thing, she had iTunes, and I would rip her entire library. Anything she was listening to was also what I was listening to. She had really crazy taste in music. She was listening to everything, so it felt like I had the whole world of music just through her, and then I could narrow that down into the things I really liked.
In high school, I had a really good friend, and he and I would only talk about music, and ride around and listen to music, and try to write music. Then that blossomed into finding that bigger space of community in college, where other people were as obsessed with music as we were.
Do you remember the first artist you discovered on your own, one that felt like your band, that you had to tell your friends about?
SCHAEFER: Yes. Two come to mind. First, a band called Daughter. I think they were from the UK. And also the songwriter Keaton Henson. I think he’s also from the UK. They’re kind of ethereal songwriters, out of the normal realm. I think that’s where I started being like, “Oh, there’s this other world that’s not on the radio, and I can go listen to it all on the internet now, because we have the internet now.”
You were born in Missouri and moved to Mississippi. Did you have live music nearby?
SCHAEFER: I was about an hour away from Memphis, so if there was something I really, really wanted to see, I could go there. And thirty minutes away was Oxford, Mississippi, where smaller bands would come through. But when I was in high school, I guess I just didn’t know where to look for those things. I spent a lot of time at home in my bedroom watching things on YouTube. I don’t know that I ever really went to shows until I got to college. That’s when I started going to shows in my college town, and then also driving around the state to find more.
Were those mostly small indie bands and friends’ bands, or arena shows?
SCHAEFER: Mostly the small bands. I remember the first show I saw in college was a house show just down the street from the college. It was local bands. I went to school in Cleveland, which is in the Delta. One of the bands was from Oxford, called the Holy Ghost Electric Show, and the other was a band called Scott’s House, whose lead singer is now one of my best friends, because she was also in school there. It was at a house-show venue in town called Lucy’s Tough Luck Diner. That was my first experience going out to a show, and it really changed my life, I think.
At that point, did it look like something you could pull off, or did it take you a while to imagine yourself on that stage?
SCHAEFER: I thought it was fun, and I have always had the delusion that I was going to do that. Even as a child, I knew that I wanted to. But seeing it happening in front of me, with people who were not that different from me, made me realize how accessible and how realistic that delusion could really be.
On the record, is it more of a democracy, with everybody adding their own parts, or is it your vision, with other people helping you find it?
SCHAEFER: It’s both. It definitely starts with the song. I have the song to show them, and they start filling in the gaps. I love working with people who are excited about whatever they’re working on, so that they want to bring their best selves to it. I’m really grateful that my friends Starlin (Browning) and Ben (Yarbrough) and Taylor (Whyte) have always been willing to do that with me. They come in, they listen, and then they figure out how to support whatever’s happening.
I think Ben specifically shines on this record, because he has all these really fun guitar melodies that play really nicely with the song as a whole. I love hearing their ideas. It wouldn’t sound the way it does without them.
You’ve mentioned Jimbo and Matt as mentors. Can you hear their influence in your songs?
SCHAEFER: I hear their influence and mentorship. Jimbo played on one song on the record, and it wasn’t even one of the songs that he wrote. But I think it goes back to what I said about their ethos on recording and making records. Learning from them about that stage of the process was my entire textbook for how I went about making this record: following their game plans and their processes, going in the order that they would go in to figure out a recording.
You’ve also toured with Jimbo, both solo and with the Squirrel Nut Zippers.
SCHAEFER: I’ve done both. I played guitar and sang in his solo band, which is more rock and country, and I’ve toured with them. I’ve also toured with the Squirrel Nut Zippers. Actually, I was their merch girl for a very long time. Sometimes Cella Blue, who is the current lead female vocalist, couldn’t make a show, or she was injured for part of a tour, so I was her understudy in that regard. I would fill in for her on those sets and sing some of those Squirrel Nut Zippers classics.
I know probably more than most people know, but there are still gaps in my knowledge. Especially for the Squirrel Nut Zippers, I know maybe too much about them.
And the Drive-By Truckers connection?
SCHAEFER: I’ve never toured with them. They were the backing band for Jerry Joseph on a record he did in Water Valley, Mississippi at Dial Back Sound, and I was an engineer on that record and also sang background vocals on it. Because of that session, Patterson (Hood) had me come in and sing on a Truckers record later.
You moved to Austin this year. How has that been?
SCHAEFER: It’s been really great. I’m finally, I think, getting settled in. It’s beautiful, and the musicianship here is on a level I’ve never experienced before. It’s very impressive and intimidating.
What brought you there?
SCHAEFER: I moved here because I have been singing with this band, Shinyribs, and we were going to do a lot of touring this year, so I moved here to be more settled. We just ended our big touring season, so it feels like I’m only now moving to Austin. I can now spread out, go to shows, and meet people. But I have a great community in that band, and I’ve met a lot of great people through that space.
What kind of music does Shinyribs play?
SCHAEFER: Kevin Russell is the main guy. He was in a band called The Gourds. This is kind of his next project after The Gourds. He’s from the Golden Triangle area down in Texas and Louisiana, that zone by the Gulf, so he’s got some Cajun influence, some country influence, some rock, a little bit of swamp pop. Kind of funky, fun stuff. They just put out a record a couple of weeks ago that I sang on.
Let’s talk about a few songs. What’s the story behind “Big Plains”?
SCHAEFER: “Big Plains” is a song I wrote after a tour I did out west. My friend moved out to West Texas, and she was begging me to come out: “You’ve got to come out here, I’ll book you a tour, it’ll be so fun.” We did that, and it was amazing. It changed my life. At the end of it, I wrote “Big Plains,” because it just felt like the whole world had opened up to me, and there were so many opportunities out there if I just went looking for them. I started writing that song at the end of that tour, and I ultimately finished it in Athens, Georgia, I think, with my friend Spencer that I mentioned earlier.
“Court Street” might be my favorite song on the record right now. What’s behind it?
SCHAEFER: Oh, really? That’s so cool. That song is really just a love letter to my time in Cleveland, and the friendships and relationships that happened there, especially the house where we all gathered. We called it 606, and that’s where we played shows and had our friends’ bands come through.
On the studio side of that song, we were really struggling with that one, so I’m glad to hear that it is now your favorite. We tracked that one for so long and just felt like we couldn’t get it right. Then, as a last-ditch effort, Starlin just reached over to the tape machine and slowed it down. Suddenly it was this smooth, kind of sexy little track, and we said, “Okay, this is it. This is what we’re going to build on.” My voice is lower in that song, if you’ve noticed. But it’s literally because it’s slowed down.
Does “Court Street” make the live set?
SCHAEFER: Actually, with “Court Street,” I’ve never played it live, because I have not relearned how to play it in the new key from it being slowed down. I need to.
“Skateland Baby” is the single. Is there another song you hope people latch onto?
SCHAEFER: “Mindless Feeling” is not technically a single, but it’s going to be the focus track when the album comes out. I really love that song. I feel like it’s maybe the central unifying thought of the album. I also really love “In a Scare.” I think those are two of my favorite songs on the record. Obviously, “KK’s Blues” is such a hitter. That’s not a single, but I think there’s something really special about that one. That’s one of the Jimbo songs.
How much have you played this record live?
SCHAEFER: Not a lot. I’ve only played it with a band once or twice. Everything else I’ve done has been solo.
You always wanted to be on stage. How do you deal with the nerves?
SCHAEFER: I was also pretty shy when it came to it. That was the part I really had to work through. And I still deal with the fear. I currently have this gig where I sing for Shinyribs, and we had a show last night where I was really struggling with my nervousness. I kept closing my eyes on stage, which I think is what I’ve developed as my safety mechanism: just turn off seeing people. I don’t recommend that.
I wish I could be more of an open window in that regard, because ultimately I do believe that performing on stage is supposed to be an act of connection. But that’s the scary part, and that’s the vulnerable part. For me, singing is something I can do in front of people, because that’s my favorite thing to do. But having to be vulnerable and connect with strangers can be the scary thing.
Do you play shows where people are there to catch up with their friends, standing three feet in front of you, and talking through your whole set? And have you also played rooms so quiet you could hear a pin drop?
SCHAEFER: Totally. Totally. They’re both uncomfortable in different ways. Obviously, if the whole room is talking, I tend to get in my head: “Oh, nobody wants to hear this. I need to wrap it up.” But then I have to remember that maybe there’s just one person out there who’s really into it. If I were that person, I would be so upset if somebody cut their set short because they’d gotten in their head about it. On the other hand, if it’s so quiet that you can hear a pin drop, I reach the same conclusion through a different route. I think, “Oh, everybody’s so bored. Nobody wants to hear this. I need to wrap it up.”
Do you ever get into a zone and come off stage thinking, “Wow, I just played ten songs”?
SCHAEFER: Yes, for sure. Especially if I’m having a good night, or especially enjoying that set, I can definitely come off stage thinking, “Let’s go again!” But probably more often, I’ll think, “Oh, I think people probably would have liked less of that.” My problem is that I have been opening for other bands, and I think, “They are just so ready to get through me and hear who they came to see.” But then somebody will very earnestly and very kindly come up afterward and tell me how they felt about the set, and that reminds me that there’s always that one person.
Are you planning to tour behind the album?
SCHAEFER: Oh, yes, I’m hoping to tour. I already have something that I can’t say anything about yet, but it’s just me on an opening slot for another artist, so whenever they tell me I’m allowed to tell people. As far as the album goes, we’ve already announced it, and I don’t have any plans to tour as of yet. I’m hoping to start that within the next year.
If we got on a Zoom call a year from now, what would you hope to tell me about the year you’d had?
SCHAEFER: Oh, wow. I hope I’ve been playing music, and I hope I’ve been writing music. And I hope I’ve played in Columbus, and you’ve gotten to see it live.
Is there a particular milestone you’d love to hit?
SCHAEFER: I would love to play Newport Folk Fest. I went one year with Jimbo, and I got to sing with him and Andrew Bird. I feel ridiculous, because at the time I didn’t realize what an honor it was to be there. Now I would love to go back and sing as Schaefer.
Is there a song that takes you right back to a specific moment, the way a song on the radio can bring a memory flooding back?
SCHAEFER: I know that I have one, because that literally happened to me yesterday, but I’m really trying to think about what the song was now. Anytime I’m in a gas station and a song like that comes on, I’m struck by it. I tie music to a lot of memories, so this does happen a lot. Maybe the one that comes to mind right now is anytime I hear “Something” by Julien Baker. I’m back with my best friend Casey, commiserating and crying about whatever the thing was that day that we were crying about.
I can hear you opening for Julien Baker, boygenius, or Phoebe Bridgers. You wouldn’t be just the stopgap before the headliner. I think their fans would really like your set.
SCHAEFER: Oh man, I would love that. I am a huge fan of Julien Baker’s. That would be an honor. Thank you so much.