‘Paradise On Planet Popstar’ presents itself as both an invitation and a mirage, a record that gestures toward escape while quietly interrogating the very desire to disappear into something brighter, simpler, and more idealized. Across its two sides (Side A featuring 2023’s ‘Paradise EP’ and Side B featuring 2025 EP, ‘Planet Popstar’), Wishy construct a universe that borrows the language of dream-pop and indie rock but reshapes it into something more elusive, where melody acts as both seduction and disguise.
The opening title track “Paradise” establishes this duality with striking clarity. Kevin Krauter layers lead and rhythm guitars into a luminous wash, his bass anchoring the composition without weighing it down, while Nina Pitchkites’s voice drifts through the arrangement with a studied lightness. Paul Cherewick’s keys add a subtle iridescence, and Ben Lumsdaine’s drumming keeps the track in gentle motion, never allowing it to settle into complacency. The song suggests paradise not as a destination but as a fleeting sensation, something glimpsed rather than attained.
That sense of transience deepens on “Donut,” where Pitchkites takes a more central compositional role. Her guitar work circles itself in soft, recursive patterns, mirrored by Krauter’s multi-instrumental contributions, creating a structure that feels deliberately self-contained. The song’s cyclical quality evokes repetition not as monotony but as ritual, a return to familiar emotional states that never quite resolve. “Spinning” extends this motif, its very title hinting at disorientation. Here, Pitchkites’ rhythm guitar and vocal lines provide a steady axis while Krauter’s lead guitar arcs outward, tracing melodic lines that seem to resist gravity. Cherewick’s keys and Lumsdaine’s dual contributions on guitar and drums lend the track a subtle complexity, suggesting motion without clear direction.
“Blank Time” introduces a more introspective register, with Krauter assuming a near-total authorship over its sonic architecture. His layered guitars and bass create a dense but carefully balanced soundscape, while Pitchkites’ voice functions almost as an internal monologue, threading through the arrangement rather than dominating it.
Lumsdaine’s restrained percussion underscores the song’s preoccupation with absence, framing silence not as emptiness but as a space charged with possibility. In contrast, “Too True” expands outward, its inclusion of Steve Marino’s lead guitar adding a sharper melodic contour. The interplay between Marino and Krauter introduces a subtle friction, as though the song were negotiating between sincerity and self-awareness.
Side B shifts the record’s perspective without abandoning its central concerns. “Planet Popstar” revisits the album’s conceptual core, presenting the imagined world not as an escape from reality but as a reflection of it, refracted through pop sensibilities. “Fly” carries a sense of lift without ever fully detaching from the ground, its melodies suggesting ascent tempered by hesitation. “Over and Over” returns to cyclical structures, echoing the recursive patterns of “Donut” but with a slightly more insistent momentum, as though repetition itself were becoming harder to ignore.
“Chaser” introduces a subtle urgency, its pacing hinting at pursuit without clarifying what is being sought. This ambiguity becomes central to the album’s emotional logic, where desire is rarely named but constantly implied. “Portal” functions as a moment of passage, its textures suggesting transition rather than arrival, while “Slide” closes the record with a quiet dissolution, allowing the accumulated motifs to disperse rather than coalesce into a definitive statement.
Throughout ‘Paradise On Planet Popstar,’ Wishy demonstrate a keen awareness of how pop structures can both reveal and obscure emotional truth. The interplay between Krauter and Pitchkites forms the album’s core, their shared and alternating roles creating a dialogue that feels both intimate and unresolved. Lumsdaine’s presence as drummer, percussionist, and engineer ensures a cohesive sonic identity, while Cherewick’s keys and Marino’s guitar contributions add dimension without disrupting the record’s internal logic. What distinguishes the album is its refusal to treat escapism as either naive or inherently suspect. Instead, it presents the impulse to imagine alternate worlds as a natural extension of emotional life, one that can illuminate as much as it conceals. Paradise, in this context, is not a fixed place but a shifting construct, shaped by memory, desire, and the persistent awareness that any ideal is, by definition, incomplete.
Please visit Winspear | Wishy | Bandcamp | Instagram | Twitter for more information.
